Table of Contents
Phoenix Rising FC: Making the Case for Promotion and Relegation in American Soccer
In the scorching Arizona heat, Phoenix Rising Football Club has consistently overcome challenging conditions to become a dominant force in the United Soccer League (USL). Their 2023 season, capped by a thrilling championship victory, exemplifies the club's ambitions and raises a compelling question: is Phoenix Rising the most convincing case for adopting a promotion and relegation model in modern U.S. soccer?
A Championship Season: Rising’s Historic Triumph
Phoenix Rising captured the USL Championship title in dramatic fashion, overcoming an early deficit to defeat Charleston Battery on penalties following a tense 1-1 draw. Charleston took the lead early through Nick Markanich, but Phoenix's resilience shone late in the match. In the 89th minute, winger Danny Trejo's exceptional hustle led to John Stenberg's decisive equalizer, sparking jubilant celebrations.
Stenberg, a relatively unknown Swedish defender with limited appearances in the USL, proved pivotal in the club’s championship run, underlining Phoenix's astute scouting strategy and adaptability.
Key MLS Experience Fueling Phoenix’s Rise
The foundation of Phoenix Rising’s success lies significantly in its strategic acquisitions of players with Major League Soccer (MLS) backgrounds. Manuel Arteaga stood out prominently, providing crucial goals and becoming a significant offensive presence. His performances will likely attract attention from MLS scouts in the offseason.
Danny Trejo, formerly of LAFC, leveraged his MLS experience to provide creativity and critical contributions, including 24 goal involvements during the regular season. Renzo Zambrano (ex-Portland Timbers) and Alejandro Fuenmayor (ex-Houston Dynamo) further enhanced Phoenix's squad, offering invaluable experience and leadership. Additionally, the mid-season loan signing of Mohammed Traore from LAFC rounded out the talent-rich roster, reflecting a clear strategic vision.
Could Phoenix Thrive in MLS?
Phoenix Rising’s consistent success and community engagement present a compelling argument for promotion into MLS. Their planned soccer-specific stadium at 38th Street & Washington symbolizes the club's deep-rooted commitment to local soccer culture. While expansion would be necessary, the existing passionate fan base and community connections offer a robust foundation for sustained MLS success.
Sports agent Pedro Breganholi endorses this sentiment: “Undoubtedly, Phoenix Rising would be a great addition to Major League Soccer.” With prominent names like Didier Drogba, Diplo, and Pete Wentz in the ownership group, the club has experienced remarkable stability and ambition since its rebranding in 2017.
Promotion/Relegation: Practical Challenges and Opportunities
While the theoretical merits of a pro/rel system excite fans, practical realities must be addressed. Financial sustainability, infrastructure upgrades, and competitive readiness are critical factors. The challenges faced by clubs transitioning to MLS—such as recent expansion side Saint Louis City SC—illustrate the complexities and potential rewards of this shift.
Phoenix Rising represents an ideal case study, demonstrating how calculated investments and community-driven initiatives can prepare a team for higher competition levels. Yet, integrating promotion and relegation requires careful planning, robust financial frameworks, and clear pathways.
Looking Forward: Phoenix Rising and the Future of U.S. Soccer
The journey for Phoenix Rising FC is about more than winning trophies—it's about pioneering a path toward a more dynamic American soccer structure. Their sustained success, solid local support, and strategic player acquisitions highlight their readiness to compete at the highest levels.
As debates around pro/rel continue, Phoenix Rising stands as a compelling candidate for testing the model's viability. Their recent achievements could catalyze a broader conversation on evolving the American soccer landscape. The question remains for the decision-makers in U.S. soccer: can a clear path be established for ambitious, successful clubs like Phoenix Rising to ascend organically?
The coming years will reveal if Phoenix’s rise signals a new era or remains merely a powerful example of what could be.
