LAFC Faces Turbulent Transition: Cherundolo’s Exit Signals Turning Point for the Club

LAFC’s loss to Messi‘s Miami, and a new coach in Mascherano wasn’t just tactical — it was symbolic. This was a tournament the club and its fanbase had circled. A deep run would have solidified LAFC’s status as a continental contender and offered redemption for the setbacks of 2023: a Concacaf final defeat to Club León and the MLS Cup loss to Columbus. Instead, the early exit added to a mounting sense of frustration across the organization.

Rumors of internal tension began to surface almost immediately. In the hours after the defeat, fans took to social media calling for a coaching change — this wasnt a surprising move, as Cherundolo’s wife publicly defended him in the comments after one fan dated to publicly criticize the former USMNT standout for his lack of performance in marquee matches. Mrs. Cherundolo wife’s post hinted not only at weariness with the criticism but perhaps a shared desire to return to Europe. Weeks later, Cherundolo announced he would step down at season’s end.

Again, the timing isn’t shocking. Over four seasons, Cherundolo delivered a respectable haul: one MLS Cup, a Supporters’ Shield, and a U.S. Open Cup title. But the recent pattern of high-stakes losses — and the inability to establish dominance in international competition — likely eroded internal support that led to a mutual department agreement at season end.

As for who comes next, one name makes more sense than most: Giorgio Chiellini. The Italian legend, who recently returned to Juventus in an executive role, knows the club culture and was a trusted voice under Cherundolo. Though his availability is uncertain, his profile stands out amid other possible successors like assistants Ante Razov or Marc Dos Santos, or even a wildcard hire from abroad — a path that’s worked for clubs like the Vancouver Whitecaps.

Regardless of the replacement, LAFC is entering a pivotal phase. The foundation is in place—a competitive team, a passionate fanbase, and global ambitions. However, after this week, it’s evident that a new era must commence. The margin for error for a second club in a city that swiftly loses interest in anything that isn’t flashy and new will diminish significantly from now on.